Deprecated: strlen(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/mom/module/pub/view-inc.php on line 105
Repository | Book | Chapter
Finding a world in labor
Hannah Arendt, women's writings from the self-respect movement in India, and the emergence of an interactionist multi-world thesis for feminist phenomenology
pp. 133–155
Abstract
As feminist philosophers critique aspects of the world, a feminist phenomenological approach has the potential to not only reveal new insights for a critique, but may also serve as a novel method for generating a framework of world as a phenomenological category, which is accessed, revealed, and to a certain extent, constructed through our modes of relating to it. This chapter is geared toward formulating a feminist phenomenology of the world through an articulation of what I call, a multi-world thesis. Through a reading of Hannah Arendt’s conceptualization of the vita activa in The Human Condition, I delineate the possibility of such a thesis. I, however, go on to critique aspects of the Arendtian understanding of the world as being hierarchical. Such a hierarchical model of the world as well as Arendt’s approach to labor, I argue, are cause for worry from a feminist and anti-caste perspective. If these problems are not addressed, the multi-dimensional conceptualization of the world would lose its critical edge and, in fact, threatens to degenerate into what we may characterize as the vertical stacking of worlds. In a model of vertical stacking, differential values are attributed to each layer, and only some versions of the world are considered to be archetypical. The phenomenological dimension of the world, which situates us the closest to natural processes and the body (especially, the body in labor), faces the worst plight on the Arendtian scheme. On my part, I reconstruct the multi-world thesis in an egalitarian vein by developing an alternative phenomenology of labor. On the path toward reconstruction, I engage with the works of women in the Self-Respect movement from early twentieth century colonial India. Labor is shown to be a site for finding the world instead of losing the world. The reconstruction of the multi-world thesis in light of a new feminist phenomenology of labor ultimately generates an interactionist version of the multi-world thesis as opposed to a vertical stacking of worlds. Since the writings studied from the Self-Respect movement predate many phenomenological theorizations of the world rooted in Eurocentric philosophical perspectives, including that of Arendt, this chapter also hopes to stipulate a new lineage into both the phenomenology of the world and the phenomenology of labor from the Global South.
Publication details
Published in:
Chunodkar Sonali A, de Warren Nicolas (2026) Phenomenology in India: new vistas and approaches. Cham-Heidelberg-New York-Dordrecht-London, Springer.
Pages: 133–155
DOI: 10.1007/978-3-032-20873-6_7
Full citation:
Banerjee Amrita (2026) „Finding a world in labor: Hannah Arendt, women's writings from the self-respect movement in India, and the emergence of an interactionist multi-world thesis for feminist phenomenology“, In: S.A. Chunodkar & N. De Warren (eds.), Phenomenology in India, Cham-Heidelberg-New York-Dordrecht-London, Springer, 133–155.


